Informational Only · Not Legal Advice · Not a Law Firm · Editorial Policy

Security Negligence Lawsuit: When Is a Property Liable for Injury?

A property owner is liable for an injury caused by a third party's criminal act when the harm was foreseeable and the owner failed to take reasonable security precautions against it. Foreseeability is the whole fight: it usually turns on what the owner knew or should have known before the attack — prior crimes on or near the property, a specific warning, or conditions that made violence likely — not on how obvious the danger looks afterward. "Negligent security" is the common name for this claim, a branch of premises liability. It is not a class action, even though it often involves the same defendants — apartment operators, retail chains, hotels, parking garage owners — and the rules now vary sharply by state, because legislatures in Florida and Georgia have rewritten them in the last two years.

Table of Contents

The four elements a negligent security claim has to prove

Every negligent security case rests on the same chain. The owner or operator owed the injured person a duty of care; the risk of a criminal attack was foreseeable; the owner failed to act reasonably in light of that risk; and that failure helped cause the injury. Duty depends on why you were there.

Advertisement

Invitees — customers, tenants, guests, delivery drivers — get the most protection. Trespassers typically get almost none, and several states now say so by statute. The doctrinal baseline most states still apply comes from Restatement (Second) of Torts § 344, described in analysis published by the Texas Real Estate Research Center: a business possessor is liable to invitees for third-party criminal acts when it knows or has reason to know, from past experience, that conduct endangering visitors is likely. The phrase "from past experience" is why these cases are built out of police reports and incident logs rather than opinions about whether a place feels unsafe.

How courts decide an attack was foreseeable

Texas is the strictest model and the clearest illustration. Owners there generally owe no duty to protect against third-party criminal acts at all, under *Walker v. Harris*, 924 S.W.2d 375 (Tex. 1996). A duty appears only when the crime was foreseeable, and *Timberwalk Apartments v. Cain* (Tex. 1998) set the test courts still use, published by the Texas Supreme Court: prior crimes weighed for proximity, recency, frequency, similarity and publicity.

Those five factors do real work. A single burglary two miles away four years ago is not notice of a sexual assault in a stairwell. Eleven armed robberies in the same parking lot in eighteen months is. The factors are a floor, not a ceiling. In *Del Lago Partners v. Smith* (Tex. 2010), the Texas Supreme Court held that the Timberwalk factors "are not the only reasons that a criminal act might be deemed foreseeable" — the character of the premises and conduct unfolding immediately before the attack can establish it on their own. A bar that watches a ninety-minute escalation and does nothing cannot say it had no prior similar incidents.

Florida's safe-harbor statute and what it demands of landlords

Florida took a different route: it gave multifamily residential owners a way to earn protection by actually installing security. Under section 768.0706 of the 2026 Florida Statutes, an owner or principal operator who "substantially implements" a listed set of measures gets a presumption against liability for criminal acts committed by third parties on the premises. The burden of proving implementation sits on the owner.

The list is specific, which makes it checkable. It includes: Two limits matter for tenants. The statute required crime-deterrence and safety training for existing employees by January 1, 2025, and it expressly creates no private cause of action. It is a shield an owner raises in an existing suit, not a claim a resident can file for a missing deadbolt.

  • Lighting in walkways, laundry rooms, common areas and porches, illuminated from dusk until dawn or controlled by photocell
  • A deadbolt of at least one inch in each dwelling-unit door
  • Camera recordings retained for 30 days
  • Locked pool gates and peepholes on unit doors
  • A crime prevention through environmental design (CPTED) assessment less than three years old

Georgia's 2025 rewrite, and the verdict that caused it

Georgia changed its rules after a single case made the exposure plain. In *CVS Pharmacy v. Carmichael*, decided June 29, 2023, a customer was shot during an armed robbery in a CVS parking lot. The Georgia Supreme Court's opinion addressed a jury apportionment of 95% of the fault to CVS, 5% to the plaintiff, and 0% to the man who pulled the trigger.

📨 Get Free Mass Tort Guides Alerts

Free · No spam · Unsubscribe anytime

Governor Brian Kemp signed SB 68 on April 21, 2025, creating a new Article 5 at O.C.G.A. §§ 51-3-50 through 51-3-57 governing premises claims based on third-party wrongful conduct. According to a memorandum from the law firm HunterMaclean dated May 7, 2025, the article applies to causes of action arising on or after that date — so the date of the injury, not the date of filing, decides which law governs. A plaintiff under the new article must show either a particularized warning of imminent wrongful conduct, or that the owner should have known harm was likely from prior similar incidents. The statute also supplies defenses covering trespassers, injuries occurring off the premises, an owner's inability to exclude the wrongdoer, and calling 911.

Parking lots, garages, and where these cases concentrate

If there is a single physical setting behind negligent security litigation, it is the parking area. FBI NIBRS data for 2019 recorded 77,154 crimes-against-persons offenses at locations coded "Parking/Drop Lot/Garage." That is the ground where *Carmichael* and much of the case law sit, and the reason is structural.

Lots are open, poorly lit at the edges, rarely patrolled, and they put people alone next to their belongings at predictable times. For an owner, that concentration is where the cheapest fixes are: working lights, functioning cameras with retained footage, trimmed sightlines, and a documented assessment. For an injured person, it is where the evidence is — footage that may be overwritten within weeks, and a police call history that will show whether this was the first incident or the twelfth.

Practical steps after an injury on someone else's property

The record that decides these cases is built in the first few weeks, and most of it is held by the defendant. Liability also does not require that the owner could have stopped the specific attacker. It requires that reasonable precautions against a foreseeable risk were skipped — and under Texas law, foreseeability is judged on what the owner knew beforehand, never in hindsight.

  • Report the crime to police and get the incident number; the department's own call history for that address becomes the prior-similar-incidents evidence.
  • Photograph the conditions that night — burned-out fixtures, a propped gate, a broken lock — before they are repaired.
  • Note every camera you can see, and have a lawyer send a preservation letter fast: Florida's own standard contemplates retention of only 30 days.
  • Get names of staff on duty and of other tenants or customers who have complained before.
  • Check which state's rules apply and when your injury occurred, since Georgia's new article turns on a cause of action arising on or after April 21, 2025.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a property have to hire security guards?

No. The duty is to act reasonably against a foreseeable risk, and the reasonable response may be lighting, locks, cameras, or gates. Florida's statute lists measures of exactly that kind rather than requiring personnel.

Can I sue if I was injured just outside the property line?

It is much harder, and in Georgia the new article includes an express defense for injuries occurring off the premises.

Does the criminal being unidentified end my case?

No. The claim is against the owner for its own negligence. In *CVS Pharmacy v. Carmichael* the jury assigned the shooter 0% of the fault and CVS 95%.

Can I use Florida's section 768.0706 to sue my landlord for missing deadbolts?

No. That statute expressly does not establish a private cause of action; it functions as a liability presumption for owners who prove they implemented the listed measures.


You Might Also Like

Owed money from a settlement? Check what is open at OpenClassActions.com. Caring for someone with dementia? Find practical guides at HelpDementia.com. Working out a skin routine? Evidence-based answers at AcneAdvocate.com. Forgot the name of a movie? Identify it at FindThisMovie.com. Was your data exposed? Track active breaches at DataBreachRadar.com.

We use cookies to run this site, measure how it’s used, and show ads. Choose “Essentials only” to limit cookies to what the site needs to work. Privacy Policy.